Two Masterpieces of Shinsengumi History and Lore

img_1495

Shimosawa Kan’s Shinsengumi Shimatsuki is one of the earliest accounts of the Shinsengumi. It was first published in 1928, just before Hirao Michio’s groundbreaking history Shinsengumi Shiroku (新撰組史緑; original title, Shinsengumishi, 新撰組史). As I mention in my Shinsengumi: The Shogun’s Last Samurai Corps, Shimosawa’s narrative is partially based on interviews with former corpsmen and other people who had direct contact with the Shinsengumi. But he was first and foremost a novelist. He began the preface of his book by stating, “It is not my intention to write history.” Some of his information has been repudiated by more recent studies, whose authors have enjoyed the benefits of nearly a century of subsequent scholarship unavailable to Shimosawa. Accordingly, like other early historical narratives of the Shinsengumi, Shimosawa’s book should best be taken for what it’s worth, and relished for its portrayal of the spirit of the men of Shinsengumi rather than a faithful history.

Hirao, on the other hand, was an historian, widely known for his writings about Tosa history including biographies of Sakamoto Ryoma, Nakaoka Shintaro and Yamauchi Yodo.

I have many books about the Shinsengumi in my private library. This edition of Shimosawa’s book (photo above), published in 1967, which I found in a used bookstore in Tokyo’s Kanda district years ago, is one of my prized possessions.


My Shinsengumi: The Shogun’s Last Samurai Corps, is the only history of the Shinsengumi in English.
 Shinsengumi

Takasugi Shinsaku and the Chōshū Domain

Takasugi Shinsaku

During the first two months of 1866, around two years before the fall of the Tokugawa Bakufu, the anti-Bakufu rebels in Chōshū, led by the indomitable young samurai Takasugi Shinsaku, ousted the ruling conservatives in a bloody civil war. As leader of Chōshū’s powerful army, Takasugi envisaged Chōshū as becoming “the most powerful and wealthy nation among the five great continents.”

Chōshū (modern-day Yamaguchi Prefecture) was one of two samurai clans most responsible for overthrowing the Bakufu and bringing about the Meiji Restoration. The other was its rival Satsuma (modern-day Kagoshima Prefecture). After the United States, Great Britain, France and others forced unfair trade treaties on the thus far isolated country in 1858, samurai from Chōshū, Satsuma, and other parts of Japan, most notably Tosa (modern-day Kochi Prefecture and home domain of Sakamoto Ryōma), called for a “strong military and rich nation” under a newly restored monarchy to fend off Western imperialism. They developed a military strong enough to overthrow the Tokugawa Bakufu, which, under the shogun, had ruled the country for over two and a half centuries.

For Takasugi “the five great continents” were synonymous with “the world,” suggesting his belief that Japan’s future lay with Chōshū. And to a great extent he was right. Former samurai of Chōshū and Satsuma would control the Meiji government into the twentieth century. During its infancy, the new Meiji government was dominated by the triad of Saigō Takamori, Ōkubo Toshimichi, and Kido Takayoshi (formerly Katsura Kogorō), and the Court nobles Sanjō Sanétomi and Iwakura Tomomi. After the deaths of Saigō, Ōkubo, and Kido within one year of each other (Kido of illness in May 1877, Saigō on the battlefield that September, Ōkubo by assassination in May 1878), the Japanese government continued to be dominated by Satsuma and Chōshū men, including Itō Hirobumi, Inoué Kaoru and Yamagata Aritomo. Itō, architect of the Meiji Constitution of 1889, was the Meiji government’s first prime minister (from 1885 to 1888). Of the first fourteen cabinets (1885 to 1912), eight were led by former Chōshū samurai (Itō, four times Yamagata Aritomo, twice; Katsura Tarō, twice), and three by men of Satsuma (Kuroda Kiyotaka, once; Matsukata Masayoshi, twice). And while Katsu Kaishū, “the shōgun’s last samurai” of my Samurai Revolution, headed up the Imperial Navy in its nascent years, after Saigō’s death the Imperial Army was dominated by Yamagata, though Satsuma’s naval leadership was stronger than Chōshū’s. It is noteworthy that current Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is a descendent of Chōshū samurai.

Related articles:

Takasugi Shinsaku’s Indomitable Spirit

Takasugi Shinsaku: The Dynamic Leader of the Choshu Rebels

Takasugi Shinsaku: “To Think While on the Run”

Prime Minister Abe’s Choshu Connection


Takasugi Shinsaku, along with Chōshū and Satsuma,  features prominently in Samurai Revolution.

644502_247397672083151_1209814990_n

widget_buy_amazon

“The Ryoma Phenomenon” (15): Ryoma and Nietzsche (2)

180px-sakamoto_ryomaNietzsche187a

As I wrote in No. 1 of this series, Ryōma began living dangerously when he rejected Confucian-samurai values and the discriminatory class structure in Tosa, fled Tosa, and became an outlaw.

Ryōma’s rejection of certain Confucian-samurai values (by no means did he reject them all) resembles Nietzsche’s rejection of Christian values, just as the philosopher’s famous announcement of the death of God is comparable to Ryōma’s heralding the death of Tokugawa feudalism. According to Nietzsche, once a person rejects society’s old values, he is left with nothing but himself to rely on. This fundamental Nietzschean idea is reflected in an often-cited poem by Ryōma, which, I think, sums up the latter’s philosophy very nicely: “It matters not what people say of me, I am the only one who knows what I must do.” (世の人はわれを なにともゆはゞいへわがなすことはわれのみぞしる)


ryoma
widget_buy_amazon

“Samurai Assassins”: The Assassination of Sakamoto Ryoma

imai
“Since Sakamoto was no good for the Bakufu or the Imperial Court…, I thought we had to kill him.” Imai Nobuo, formerly of Bakufu security force Mimawarigumi, speaking years after the fact.
“The Assassination of Sakamoto Ryoma” is the title of Part III of my forthcoming Samurai Assassins: “Dark Murder” and the Meiji Restoration, 1853-1868, to be published by McFarland in spring 2017.

hillsborough_978-1-4766-6880-2
widget_buy_amazon

“The Ryoma Phenomenon” (14): Ryoma and Nietzsche (1)

 

180px-sakamoto_ryomaNietzsche187a

I began studying the life of Sakamoto Ryōma in the mid-1980’s to research my novel Ryoma: Life of a Renaissance Samurai. It was during that time that I discovered the underlying theme of his life: a relentless quest for freedom. Immediately following the scene in which he flees Tosa, I wrote that “abandoning Tosa was Ryoma’s giant leap across the border which had separated him from freedom,” and that he “had chosen to throw himself into a cauldron of political and social chaos” for freedom. “Freedom was what Ryoma had longed for, and it was for freedom that he had sacrificed both country and home. The freedom to act, the freedom to think, the freedom to be: these were the ideals that drove him on the thorny road toward salvation, the salvation of Japan.”

It wasn’t until much later that I delved into the works of Nietzsche, another famous lover of freedom. I discovered that despite their vastly different historical, cultural, and ideological backgrounds, Ryōma and Nietzsche were kindred spirits. I perceived an uncanny resemblance between the provocative German thinker whose ideas resonate throughout the twentieth century and beyond, and the audacious samurai who changed history. Ryōma and Nietzsche were contemporaries, though the latter lived many years longer than the former; and both were modern thinkers. But while Nietzsche was a philosopher, Ryōma was a man of action who lived some of Nietzsche’s fundamental ideas, including the exhortation to “live dangerously.”

“I welcome all signs that a more virile, warlike age is about to begin, which will restore honor to courage above all. For this age shall prepare the way for one yet higher, and it shall give the strength that this higher age will require some day—the age that will carry heroism into the search for knowledge and that will wage wars for the sake of ideas and their consequences. To this end we now need many preparatory courageous human beings. . .” .And so, Nietzsche exhorts courageous human beings who are “seekers of knowledge” to “live dangerously!” [Nietzsche, Friedrich. Walter Kaufmann, trans. The Gay Science, sec. 283. New York: Vintage-Random, 1974. The philosopher R. J. Hollingdale points out that here Nietzsche is not inciting people to arms, as he is often misunderstood to do. His gist, rather, is seen in an earlier line of Nietzsche’s: “Strife is the perpetual food of soul.” (Hollingdale, R. J. Nietzsche: The Man and His Philosophy, p. 144. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1999)]

Ryōma was indeed a seeker of knowledge; and though he was a warrior, he was also a peacemaker. The knowledge he sought included Western military science, and modern business and governmental systems to develop a modern navy, establish Japan’s first modern trading company, and write the blueprint for the modern Meiji government. Commanding a Chōshū warship in 1866, he waged war for the sake of ideas and their consequences against Tokugawa forces at Shimonoseki. In arranging for a military alliance between Satsuma and Chōshū against the Bakufu, and composing a plan for the shōgun’s peaceful abdication and restoration of Imperial rule, even while running guns for the revolution, he proved to be a preparatory courageous human being, even in defiance of his allies, Satsuma and Chōshū, who were determined to crush the Bakufu by military force, and his enemies in the Bakufu who opposed the shōgun’s decision to abdicate.

Ryōma began living dangerously when he rejected Confucian-samurai values and the discriminatory class structure of his native Tosa, fled Tosa, and became an outlaw. In 1865, as he worked to broker the Satsuma-Chōshū Alliance, he wrote a letter to his sister Otomé, in which he dismissed men who stayed behind in Tosa as “truly very stupid” for “spending their days in a place like [Tosa] without any ambition at all.” In the following year, he wrote to Otomé, “Rather than staying home . . . and receiving a stipend of rice, it is much more fun to be working for the nation, if only one is prepared to lay down his life.” Ryōma perceived the Bakufu’s Confucian-based social and political systems as a threat to Japan’s sovereignty in an age of Western imperialism; and resolved to live dangerously, he was determined to overthrow the Bakufu.


ryoma
widget_buy_amazon